Andover Townsman, Andover, MA


January 31, 2013

Dalton column: Innkeepers' dispute

In 1680 the General Court allowed Andover to have two public houses (inns) and that opened the door, so to speak, for some trouble.

By 1689, John Osgood had been an innholder for some time and didn’t like the competition he was receiving from the elderly William Chandler, who had become an innkeeper in 1687, so Osgood complained to the county court that Chandler didn’t have a license to sell cider and strong drink. Each of these men were among the original settlers of the town, and the feud was likely watched carefully by the town’s small population.

In order to establish his continuing right to be an innholder, Chandler was put to the work of finding the proper documentation and then adding an affidavit from five men who stated Chandler’s inn was necessary. They lived on the roads from Andover to Ipswich and Billerica, and stated in the affidavit that prior to Chandler’s “Horseshoe,” as it was called, they often heard strangers complain there was no public house of entertainment on those roads and the strangers had to travel a mile and a half out of their way for a bed and refreshment or, even worse, intrude upon private houses. That intrusion, said the five men, was burdensome to the neighborhood; therefore, William Chandler’s house was located in a convenient location for innkeeping.

A year after Osgood’s original complaint, 35 Andover men filed a lengthy petition critical of Chandler. For the benefit of my readers, I have abbreviated that bloviated petition; where there are words in quotation marks, they come from the petition itself, as copied in historian Sarah Loring Bailey’s 1880 book, “Historical Sketches of Andover.”

The petitioners stated they spoke for “many more, if not most of the town,” and said Chandler’s behavior had become an “epidemicall evil that overspreads and is like to corrupt the greater part of our towne if not speedily prevented.” The petitioners continued, “ his first setting up he seemed to have had tendernesse upon his conscience not to admit of excess or disorder in his house... but the earnest desire for money hath proved an evil root to him... for through his over forwardness to promote his own gaine he hath been apt to animate and entice persons to spend their own money & time to ye great wrong of themselves and family they belong to.”

Text Only | Photo Reprints

    Courtesy Photo Boy Scout Troop 76 based at Ballard Vale Church in Andover traveled to Mt. Cranmore last month for its annual Ski Trip.

    Ski trip for Troop 76 Boy Scouts Posted 5 days ago 2 Photos
  • Kiwanis Club readies annual charitable Feast Posted 5 days ago
  • GREEK2

    Courtesy photo The students from Greek Language School of Andover demonstrate a traditional dance at Sts. Constantine and Helen Church during a program commemorating the 1821 Greek War of Independence.

    Celebration of Greek independence Posted 5 days ago 2 Photos

    Share your memories of Colleen Ritzer Posted 12 days ago 1 Photo
  • 'Book of Golden Deeds' nominees sought Posted 12 days ago

    Maya Schwinn-Clanton was paired with Wenzel in the "Shamrocks" group.

    A lucky day for young equestrians Posted 12 days ago 6 Photos

    Courtesy Photo Norman Humer, right, with Mark Aquino at the Eastern Massachusetts Bridge Association winter sectional tournament.

    Townspeople Posted 12 days ago 2 Photos
  • Thursday, March 27, 2014

    William Stearns

    Townspeople Posted 19 days ago 1 Photo

    Courtesy photo Participating in the Merrimack Valley YMCA Social Entrepreneurship Institute's recent 10-day trip to India were, bottom left to right, J. Shamila Doris, secretary of the Madurai YMCA, which is a parner to the local Y; Rev. S. Suyambu, general secretary of the Madurai YMCA; Stephen Ives, president and CEO of the Merrimack Valley YMCA; Deborah Hope, Merrimack Valley YMCA board member; Cathleen Landry, chief financial officer of the Merrimack Valley YMCA; Katie DesBois, director of grant management and research for the Merrimack Valley YMCA; Rosa Lopez, secretary of the Merrimack Valley YMCA board; Anne Whalen, executive director of the Methuen YMCA; Ali Beauchamp, business manager of the Lawrence YMCA; Shannon Delany, YMCA Day Camp Otter director' and Alex Turek, executive director of the Andover/North Andover YMCA

    YMCA leaders take entrepreneurial trip to India Posted 19 days ago 1 Photo
  • Thursday, March 20, 2014

    Courtesy photo Patients line up to receive free medical care in rural Louisiana. Navy Reserve Lt. Cmdr. Charles F. McQuade, a dentist from Andover, was among about 120 Navy and Air National Guard medical professionals who participated in Cajun Care.

    Local dentist pitches in for Operation Cajun Care Posted 26 days ago 2 Photos

Pictures of the Week